Robert Morse
Morse is
into herbs and glandulars (not vegan), but he has some great info
too, he and I being on the same page on a lot of issues. But sometimes
he is someone who is "talking out of their hat". For
example, to say someone using inorganic iodine will cause hyperthyroidism
is an example of "a little knowledge can be a dangerous thing".
If he was fully educated on the subject he wouldn't be saying
this. How does he explain all the people who had hyperthyroidism
who got rid of it by taking inorganic iodine? (along with iodine's
co-factor nutrients). So those who follow Morse 100% will not
consider an iodine supplement, and this could negatively affect
their health.
Some educators, like Morse, have an opinion on every aspect of
health, maybe because they feel they are assumed to have one,
so to have maximal credibility they feel they should have one,
so they do. But presenting opinions as facts is irresponsible.
Don't get me wrong, Morse has lots of 100% correct, spot-on info,
but this does not mean that all his info is 100%
correct. This is why I can't recommend him as someone to "follow"
because the average person would not be able to distinguish fact
from "opinion presented as fact".
Here's what
a few people wrote about him, and I concur.
"Morse
discourages other isolated nutrients like B12; he's definitely
a die hard raw foodist with a passion for herbal tinctures and
glandulars. He carries a lot of weight physically, so he obviously
doesn't practice what he preaches. So Dr. Morse is a mixed bag."
"That's
what dr Morse does as well. Eats cooked foods, not always vegan.
Yet tells everyone to eat fruit." Merrie Ceri from
FB
"Are
you kidding? Morse eats all kinds of crap." Mark
Tassi
"I'm
watching a video where Morse is telling the audience about choosing
your fruit based on the vibrations you can feel (for those who
are able to do this), and he says eats fruit for breakfast and
salads for lunch, and when he got out of the woods where he
had been teaching people to have out-of-body experiences, he
was so "buzzed" he had to "ground" so he
ate at Howard Johnsons... "so there has to be balance"
he said [and he admitted to eating some Indian food today].
"But I don't eat salads." [but he just said he did].
Comments under the video were saying things like "see,
you can be supremely healthy and eat some cooked food."
Thanks Dr. Morse for giving people carte blanche to eat some
cooked food and making them think they can be just as healthy
as if they had eaten no cooked food in their diet."
Again
and this is important because it has the potential to negatively
affect people's health while Morse does advocate a fruit-based
diet, he is way off on some issues. Iodine for one. He was doing
his Q&A reading email questions, and one asked about iodine,
and although he sounded like he knew what he was talking about,
his answer was nevertheless inaccurate. I emailed him about it,
a few times, never heard back. Not caring to do peer-to-peer work
to improve what you teach when teaching health topics is irresponsible.
But Morse is not alone in this category.
I should
mention that as part of my research over the last 45 years, I've
been careful to vet not just the health information, but also
who's providing that info, because this gives clues to the potential
accuracy of the info. So I am very familiar with Morse's work.
Here are
some facts:
Morse advocates
a fruit-based diet, but pushes herbs for healing. He does not
take a "first things first" approach to healing, and
goes straight to herbs instead of exploring the possibility of
a nutritional insufficiency being at the root cause of an ill
health issue (which it is quite a lot). And the aversion to nutritional
supplements is due to the old school philosophical aversion to
them, thinking that they are worthless. Plus, Morse speaks about
things he is not qualified to speak about, yet speaks about them
in a way that sounds like he knows what he's talking about. This
has people following info that does not square with reality.
This is why,
in my opinion, arrogance and egotism have no place in certain
professions, like health educator, police officer, judge, etc.
If someone teaching pottery-making is arrogant and egotistical
and teaches some inaccurate info, what's the worst that can happen?
You make a mug that loses its handle after a few months. But when
learning from a health educator who refuses to consider that something
they're teaching is not the healthiest advice, you could lose
your health if you follow that educator 100%.
This is why
I recommend learning health info as a researcher and not as a
student. Students don't tend to question what they are taught,
but researchers question everything. And since there is so much
conflicting info in the health community even within the
raw vegan community taking a multi-source educational approach
is important if you want optimal health.
By reading
many different sources of information, you will come upon the
conflicting information, and even though most people don't like
conflicting information, researchers do, because they are searching
for the truth, and the truth is often contained somewhere in that
contradictory information. And if you are following any inaccurate
info, wouldn't you want to know about it?
A
Morse related blog post
Morse
and I teach a lot of the same things, but on some issues,
we differ, but these are not issues subject to opinion...
they are clearly in the realm of objective facts. I take
a "first
things first" approach to health restoration. Morse
does not. His approach is akin to the "do this to deal
with this and do that to deal with that" approach used
by the medical model, only Morse uses herbs. And he is against
nutritional supplements (which should be a red flag but
isn't to a lot of people who are ignorant of the facts
surrounding nutritional supplements). These aspects of his
teachings have the potential to harm people. Yes, the use
of herbs can appear to help which is why herbs have their
devoted fans, but if there was a better approach that also
would have been helpful but with no downsides, isn't that
preferable? Of course it is. But have you ever tried to
convince someone who was helped by pharma drugs that there
was also a downside to using them and they really weren't
addressing the underlying cause of their problem, but your
words fell on deaf ears (because the person was helped by
the meds)? Well, it's the same conversation for me when
I try to speak to those who are devoted to Morse because
his herbs brought them relief. The herbs did not deal with
the underlying cause of their problem, so on balance, not
the best approach.
|
Morse'
iodine misinformation
"Too
much iodine can disrupt thyroid function..."
This is incorrect. Morse has demonstrated in his videos
that he is "iodine illiterate". It is obvious
(to an iodine literate practitioner) that he has not taken
the time to research the subject thoroughly. His definition
of "too much iodine" does not square with reality.
And a normal amount of iodine can harm the body if the person
was also low in iodine's co-factor nutrients. But he doesn't
know this because he is not iodine literate.
"Intakes
of up to 500 micrograms a day of iodine are unlikely to
cause harm."
What about the women with breast cancer who are taking 400
times that amount (200 mg a day) and who aren't negatively
affected, and instead it helps resolve their breast cancer
(and does not harm their thyroid). And what about all the
people who've normalized their iodine levels and are taking
24 times that amount (12 mg) on a daily basis as a maintenance
amount for years with no damage to their thyroids? And BTW,
12 mg is 80 times the RDI for iodine. Hmmm.
"Great
sources of iodine are: figs, cranberries, strawberries,
prunes, beans (lima, green, spring), seaweed, spinach, almonds,
broccoli, fennel, whole grains, kale, watercress, coconut
oil, organic potatoes w/skin."
This demonstrates that he and his assistants don't know
what they are talking about. That should say, "The
foods that should be good sources of iodine but aren't are...".
How do we know this? Easy! Nutritional assays. You can't
argue with those, but the people who choose to believe what
they want to believe will. Amazing. The one exception is
seaweed, but it must be fresh (wet) seaweed, like the Japanese
eat. Dried seaweed contains no iodine. But fresh seaweed
only contains a maintenance amount of iodine, not a therapeutic
amount needed to address an iodine deficiency.
"...the
best plants - plants grown on iodine-rich soil
"
Where are these soils? They don't exist. They did 100,000
years ago (but not everywhere), but today they don't; not
any agri-industry soils. How do we know for 100% sure? Soil
assays... i.e., science. And empirically we can know this
from all those people who eat all the foods mentioned above
that Morse and his assistants list as "great"
sources of iodine, but these people have iodine deficiencies.
"If
you need my help w/natural healing, transitioning to #vegan
/ raw / #fruitarian detox #diet, or iridology, contact me..."
Just thought I'd throw this in for good measure...
http://health101.org/art_iridology
|
Here are
a few articles that shine a light on this important topic...
http://health101.org/blog.htm#inaccurate
http://health101.org/blog.htm#overlook
http://health101.org/art_conflicting
http://health101.org/nh
http://health101.org/science
|